The Consequences of failing Elective Noninvasive Respiratory Support as Compared to Immediate Intubation: a Population Study of Very Low Birth Weight Neonates.

INTRODUCTION Elective noninvasive respiratory support has become common. However, many neonates fail this procedure and they may require intubation. The aim of this study was to determine the relative outcome of very low birth weight neonates who failed noninvasive respiratory support compared to those that were initially intubated and mechanically ventilated. MATERIAL AND METHODS We accessed the database of every neonate who received respiratory support in 18 hospitals in the central region of Poland and examined the records for a 7-year period. The evaluation encompassed 1667 neonates with very low birth weight who were potential candidates for elective noninvasive respiratory support. Three prospective primary outcome measures were assessed using logistic regression to control for differences in baseline risk. We also examined the length of respiratory support corrected for EGA. RESULTS After controlling for significant baseline factors, we found that there was no statistically significant difference in mortality, severe retinopathy of prematurity (ROP) orsevere bronchopulmonary dysplasia (BPD) between infants failing noninvasive respiratory support and those electively intubated. However, their mortality and severe ROP were significantly higher than in those successfully treated with noninvasive respiratory support. Additionally, there was no difference in the length of mechanical ventilation or the length of all respiratory support between those that failed noninvasive support and those that were electively intubated. CONCLUSION Our study suggests that in those preterm infants who are at a higher risk of failing noninvasive ventilation there is no compelling reason to administer elective intubation and mechanical ventilation immediately after birth. It seems that efforts should rather be made towards the implementation of the optimal non-invasive respiratory support.